International Workshop: Reconfiguring Divergence: Problems, Methods, Solutions

International Workshop: Reconfiguring Divergence: Problems, Methods, Solutions

Organizer
Philipp Rössner, University of Manchester; Matthias Middell, University of Leipzig
Venue
Center for Area Studies, Leipzig
Location
Leipzig
Country
Germany
From - Until
11.04.2014 - 13.04.2014
Website
By
Rössner, Philipp

Since the times of Karl Marx and Max Weber social scientists and historians have studied the origins, causes, nature and consequences of global economic inequality. Some scholars, most notably David Landes and Eric L. Jones speculated at least implicitly about an inherent economic superiority of Europe (due to the fact that the first transition into an industrial economy occurred in Western Europe) which was sometimes interpreted as a result of implied superior cultural traits. The most recent attempt at explaining away global income disparities in the longer run comes from Acemoglu and Robinson who claim that it was inclusive (i. e. again we must say implicitly: “superior”) economic institutions that were more beneficial for economic growth than others and that it was in those regions that first implemented inclusive (i. e. non-extractive) economic institutions (i. e. post-1688 England and then north-west Europe) that we find the origins of modern economic growth, i. e. the type of trajectory that would eventually lead to industrialization. Here again it was, of course, England (and then other European regions) that came before other world regions. Since the last decade or so the idea of a “European miracle” has come under attack. Scholars have emphasized a “world of remarkable resemblances” suggesting that prior to the 1800s differentials in economic performance between Asia and Europe were less marked than usually thought, especially with regard to the potential of developing the first industrialization process. In recent years “Euro-centrist” explanations have gained some ground again.

There is still life in the “Great Divergence” metaphor; the recent dynamics in the field call for new questions, approaches and methodological configurations. The workshop brings together scholars from across the world with the aim at highlighting new approaches to the “Great Divergence”. This involves a cross-section of academic disciplines, from economics to economic history and history of migration.
It is intended to (1) provide an overview on the current state of the art regarding models and research on global income and development inequality in history (“Great Divergence”); (2) to highlight different methodological and epistemological approaches to the subject: from social & economic history to financial history, global history, Asian/Indian history, European history, colonial history, political history, area studies etc.; (3) highlight the discursive nature of the topic, especially the problem(s) that arise in terms of scope and focus of each individual narrative, depending upon each author’s methodological upbringing, training and background when studying the “Great Divergence” – and the resulting (possible) biases that may be added to the story plot. (4) Select case studies from different methodological, geographical and chronological backgrounds will address specific problems and examples of the “Great Divergence” and the origins, causes and consequences of economic inequality across time and space beyond the already known trajectories of the debate during the past decade. We would especially highlight the fact that within the greater geographical areas such as “Europe” or “Asia” there were markedly different levels of social and economic development at any point in time. There were also considerable changes and different trajectories within Europe over time that cannot be grasped within a fairly brief reference framework for the “Great Divergence” of 1750 / 1800–2013. Moreover, debates on divergence should not be too closely or exclusively modelled on an economic rationale. Factors such as culture, migration and networks also had a bearing in this process.

Programm

Friday, 11 April
7:30 pm Keynote:
Roy Bin Wong (University of California, Los Angeles): Economic Convergence and the Persistence of Difference in the 19th Century
(Location: Sommersaal Bach-Museum, Thomaskirchhof 15 / 16)

Saturday, 12 April
9:00–10:15 am Panel 1: Small Divergences? Great Divergence and the Periphery
Philipp Rössner (U Manchester / U Leipzig): Globalization, Silver and Discourses on Underdevelopment in Germany, c. 1500–1800

Georg Christ (U Manchester): A Small Divergence? The Mamluk Empire, Venetian Statehood and the Changing Economic Balance in the Eastern Mediterranean (1200–1500)

10:30–11:45 am Panel: 2 Historiographical Issues: Global History and the Great Divergence
Matthias Middell (U Leipzig): The Great Divergence Debate and its
Role within Global History

Zhang Weiwei (Tianjin U): Great Divergence or Great Convergence?
Division of Labour in Global History in a Noncentric and Holistic Perspective

1:00–2:00 pm Panel 3: Migrant Labour and Commodity Chains
Laurence Brown (U Manchester): Commodity Chains and the Globalisation of Indentured Migrant Labour: 19th Century Convergences and Disjunctures

2:15–3:45 pm Panel 4: Africa between Convergence and Divergence
Gareth Austin (U Geneva): Africa and the Great Divergence

Geert Castryck (U Leipzig): The Slow Convergence, or: Why Africa
was Conquered so Late: An Assessment of African Economic History in a Global Perspective (15th–20th C.)

4:15–5:15 pm Panel 5: India / Connectivity and Disjuncture
Ursula Rao (U Leipzig): Divergence Within: Global Cities and Local
Realities (Contemporary India)

5:30–6:00 pm Discussion

Sunday, 13 April
9:30 –10:45 am 5 The Maritime Dimension
Werner Scheltjens (U Leipzig / U Groningen): Between the Delta and the Deep Blue Sea: Reconfiguring Divergence from a Maritime Perspective

Markus A. Denzel (U Leipzig): The Re-Introduction of Commercial Institutions in an Actual Debate, or: The Importance of the System of Cashless Payment, the Maritime Insurance and the Duple-Entry Book-Keeping for the Great Divergence

Yang-wen Zheng (U Manchester): The ‘Southeast Asia Factor’ in Chinese Economic History

11:00 am –12:15 pm 6 The Great Divergence and the State
Prasannan Parthasarathi (Boston C): Great Divergence in the Anthropocene

Roy Bin Wong (UC Los Angeles): Divergent States

12:15–1:00 pm Final Discussion

Contact (announcement)

Antje Zettler
Centre for Area Studies (CAS)
University of Leipzig
Thomaskirchhof 20
04109 Leipzig
Tel: +49 341 973 78 84
Fax: +49 341 973 90 99
e-mail: cas@uni-leipzig.de


Editors Information
Published on
04.04.2014
Classification
Regional Classification
Additional Informations
Country Event
Language(s) of event
English
Language of announcement